« Clinton vs. Giuliani |
Main
| The Real Debate »
The Pathology Of Pakistan
In his last column of 2007, Mark Steyn has thoughts on what is perhaps currently the biggest security problem in the world.
...the “Federally Administered Tribal Areas” have always been somewhat loosely governed Federal Administration-wise. In the new issue of The Claremont Review Of Books, Stanley Kurtz’s fascinating round-up of various tomes by Akbar Ahmed (recently Pakistan’s High Commissioner in London and before that Political Agent in Waziristan) mentions en passant a factoid I vaguely remember from my schooldays – that even at the height of imperial power, the laws of British India, by treaty and tradition, only governed 100 yards either side of Waziristan’s main roads. Once you were off the shoulder, you were subject to the rule of various “maliks” (tribal bigshots). The British prided themselves on an ability to run the joint at arm’s length through discreet subsidy of favored locals. As a young lieutenant with the Malakand Field Force, Winston Churchill found the wiles of Sir Harold Deane, chief commissioner of the North-West Frontier Province, a tad frustrating. “We had with us a very brilliant political officer, a Major Deane, who was most disliked because he always stopped military operations,” recalled Churchill. “Apparently all these savage chiefs were his old friends and almost his blood relations. Nothing disturbed their friendship. In between fights, they talked as man to man and as pal to pal.”
The benign interpretation of Musharraf’s recent moves is that he’s doing a Major Deane. The reality is somewhat bleaker: Today, even that 200-yard corridor of nominal sovereignty has gone and Islamabad’s Political Agent is a much shrunken figure compared to his predecessors from the Raj. That doesn’t mean “foreign” influence is impossible in Waziristan. Osama bin Laden is, after all, a foreigner, and so are many of the other al-Qaeda A-listers holed up in the tribal lands. Jihadists arrested recently in Britain, Germany and Scandinavia all spent time training in Waziristan, as do Chechen rebels. If another big hit on the US mainland is currently in the works, it’s safe to say it’s being plotted somewhere in Pakistan’s tribal areas.
Posted by Rand Simberg at December 30, 2007 09:01 AM
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.transterrestrial.com/mt-diagnostics.cgi/8781
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference
this post from
Transterrestrial Musings.
Comments
There are many interesting tales about fighting on the Northwest Frontier in John Masters' excellent memoir, Bugles and a Tiger.
Men would dig tunnels from their house to the British road, and when they got tired of being besieged by some enemy, they would take a break and some fresh air on the road, in perfect safety. Then go back and continue the fight.
War and raiding were—still are—the only manly occupations. Pathans would show up after a campaign was over, and suggest that they too should get a campaign medal. After all, there wouldn't have even been a fight if they hadn't done their part!
If anyone is interested in what war among the Pathans and the Wazirs might be like for us, I recommend the book highly.
Posted by John Weidner at December 31, 2007 10:46 AM
Post a comment