« Fedora Update Update |
Main
| Future Generations »
The Hunters, Not The Hunted
Another very important Memorial Day piece, in (of all places) the New York Times.
In the past, the American public could turn to its sons for martial perspective. Soldiers have historically been perhaps the country's truest reflection, a socio-economic cross-section borne from common ideals. The problem is, this war is not being fought by World War II's citizen-soldiers. Nor is it fought by Vietnam's draftees. Its wages are paid by a small cadre of volunteers that composes about one-tenth of 1 percent of the population — America's warrior class.
The insular nature of this group — and a war that has spiraled into politicization — has left the Americans disconnected and confused. It's as if they have been invited into the owner's box to settle a first-quarter disagreement on the coach's play-calling. Not only are they unprepared to talk play selection, most have never even seen a football game.
This confusion, in turn, affects our warriors, who are frustrated by the country's lack of cohesion and the depiction of their war. Iraq hasn't been easy on the military, either. But the strength of our warriors is their ability to adapt.
Read the whole thing. Also read some eloquent thoughts from (non-American, but American in spirit) Christopher Hitchens:
"Always think of it: never speak of it." That was the stoic French injunction during the time when the provinces of Alsace and Lorraine had been lost. This resolution might serve us well at the present time, when we are in midconflict with a hideous foe, and when it is too soon to be thinking of memorials to a war not yet won. This Memorial Day, one might think particularly of those of our fallen who also guarded polling-places, opened schools and clinics, and excavated mass graves. They represent the highest form of the citizen, and every man and woman among them was a volunteer. This plain statement requires no further rhetoric.
Posted by Rand Simberg at May 29, 2006 05:28 PM
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.transterrestrial.com/mt-diagnostics.cgi/5542
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference
this post from
Transterrestrial Musings.
Comments
Soldiers have historically been perhaps the country's truest reflection, a socio-economic cross-section borne from common ideals.
Nonsense. Late 20th Century mentality.
The problem is, this war is not being fought by World War II's citizen-soldiers. Nor is it fought by Vietnam's draftees.
The problem is, those wars, despite their significance, were atypical of US military conflicts. Most US military campaigns have been fought with volunteer forces and with a public detached from, if at all aware of, the conflicts.
Posted by D Anghelone at May 30, 2006 04:32 AM
Post a comment