|
Reader's Favorites
Media Casualties Mount Administration Split On Europe Invasion Administration In Crisis Over Burgeoning Quagmire Congress Concerned About Diversion From War On Japan Pot, Kettle On Line Two... Allies Seize Paris The Natural Gore Book Sales Tank, Supporters Claim Unfair Tactics Satan Files Lack Of Defamation Suit Why This Blog Bores People With Space Stuff A New Beginning My Hit Parade
Instapundit (Glenn Reynolds) Tim Blair James Lileks Bleats Virginia Postrel Kausfiles Winds Of Change (Joe Katzman) Little Green Footballs (Charles Johnson) Samizdata Eject Eject Eject (Bill Whittle) Space Alan Boyle (MSNBC) Space Politics (Jeff Foust) Space Transport News (Clark Lindsey) NASA Watch NASA Space Flight Hobby Space A Voyage To Arcturus (Jay Manifold) Dispatches From The Final Frontier (Michael Belfiore) Personal Spaceflight (Jeff Foust) Mars Blog The Flame Trench (Florida Today) Space Cynic Rocket Forge (Michael Mealing) COTS Watch (Michael Mealing) Curmudgeon's Corner (Mark Whittington) Selenian Boondocks Tales of the Heliosphere Out Of The Cradle Space For Commerce (Brian Dunbar) True Anomaly Kevin Parkin The Speculist (Phil Bowermaster) Spacecraft (Chris Hall) Space Pragmatism (Dan Schrimpsher) Eternal Golden Braid (Fred Kiesche) Carried Away (Dan Schmelzer) Laughing Wolf (C. Blake Powers) Chair Force Engineer (Air Force Procurement) Spacearium Saturn Follies JesusPhreaks (Scott Bell) Science
Nanobot (Howard Lovy) Lagniappe (Derek Lowe) Geek Press (Paul Hsieh) Gene Expression Carl Zimmer Redwood Dragon (Dave Trowbridge) Charles Murtaugh Turned Up To Eleven (Paul Orwin) Cowlix (Wes Cowley) Quark Soup (Dave Appell) Economics/Finance
Assymetrical Information (Jane Galt and Mindles H. Dreck) Marginal Revolution (Tyler Cowen et al) Man Without Qualities (Robert Musil) Knowledge Problem (Lynne Kiesling) Journoblogs The Ombudsgod Cut On The Bias (Susanna Cornett) Joanne Jacobs The Funny Pages
Cox & Forkum Day By Day Iowahawk Happy Fun Pundit Jim Treacher IMAO The Onion Amish Tech Support (Lawrence Simon) Scrapple Face (Scott Ott) Regular Reading
Quasipundit (Adragna & Vehrs) England's Sword (Iain Murray) Daily Pundit (Bill Quick) Pejman Pundit Daimnation! (Damian Penny) Aspara Girl Flit Z+ Blog (Andrew Zolli) Matt Welch Ken Layne The Kolkata Libertarian Midwest Conservative Journal Protein Wisdom (Jeff Goldstein et al) Dean's World (Dean Esmay) Yippee-Ki-Yay (Kevin McGehee) Vodka Pundit Richard Bennett Spleenville (Andrea Harris) Random Jottings (John Weidner) Natalie Solent On the Third Hand (Kathy Kinsley, Bellicose Woman) Patrick Ruffini Inappropriate Response (Moira Breen) Jerry Pournelle Other Worthy Weblogs
Ain't No Bad Dude (Brian Linse) Airstrip One A libertarian reads the papers Andrew Olmsted Anna Franco Review Ben Kepple's Daily Rant Bjorn Staerk Bitter Girl Catallaxy Files Dawson.com Dodgeblog Dropscan (Shiloh Bucher) End the War on Freedom Fevered Rants Fredrik Norman Heretical Ideas Ideas etc Insolvent Republic of Blogistan James Reuben Haney Libertarian Rant Matthew Edgar Mind over what matters Muslimpundit Page Fault Interrupt Photodude Privacy Digest Quare Rantburg Recovering Liberal Sand In The Gears(Anthony Woodlief) Sgt. Stryker The Blogs of War The Fly Bottle The Illuminated Donkey Unqualified Offerings What she really thinks Where HipHop & Libertarianism Meet Zem : blog Space Policy Links
Space Future The Space Review The Space Show Space Frontier Foundation Space Policy Digest BBS AWOL
USS Clueless (Steven Den Beste) Media Minder Unremitting Verse (Will Warren) World View (Brink Lindsay) The Last Page More Than Zero (Andrew Hofer) Pathetic Earthlings (Andrew Lloyd) Spaceship Summer (Derek Lyons) The New Space Age (Rob Wilson) Rocketman (Mark Oakley) Mazoo Site designed by Powered by Movable Type |
Complex Failure Bleg One of the things that I'm working on is a series of case studies for failure of complex technological systems, particularly where a failure cascades (perhaps inevitably) into others. Columbia is a good example, in which the fragile leading-edge TPS was damaged during launch, which resulted in initial burnthrough during entry, which caused more internal damage, which resulted in a bigger hole in the wing, which resulted in increasing asymmetric forces on the vehicle, which resulted in eventual inability to keep the nose pointed forward, which resulted in the destructive breakup of the vehicle from aerodynamic forces. Is anyone aware of similar cases (preferably non-space, e.g., the Bonefish fire)? Posted by Rand Simberg at July 29, 2005 04:53 AMTrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.transterrestrial.com/mt-diagnostics.cgi/4086 Listed below are links to weblogs that reference this post from Transterrestrial Musings.
Comments
I remember seeing a television report about it (narrator was Jack Davenport, the series used to air on National Geographic too I think), from which I seem to remember that the chain was actually much more complex than Wikipedia shows. Best regards. *** The ICE high-speed train "Wilhelm Conrad Röntgen" was on the route from Munich to Hamburg. After stopping in Hanover at 10:30 am, the train continued its journey northwards. At 10:59 the train derailed. The cause of the disaster was a broken wheel. When passing a switch at over 200 km/h, the damaged wheel jumped off the rail. The locomotive was separated from the remaining train and the emergency brakes were activated; this braking had little effect as the braking distance was too long due to the velocity. The first four carriages made it through the road bridge that crossed the tracks at Eschede, but the fifth carriage drove against the pier. The bridge collapsed and buried two carriages, the rear carriages crashed into the wreckage and were totally torn apart. While many passengers and the driver survived in the front part of the train, there was almost no chance of survival in the rear carriages. 101 people died in the disaster. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eschede_train_disaster *** Ah! Found the NG-link: http://www.nationalgeographic.com/channel/seconds/gallery_05.html And two more links: Books with multiple case studies of failures: James Oberg, Uncovering Soviet Disasters Matthys Levy and Mario Salvadori, Why Buildings Fall Down (all civil engineering, probably not as complex a cascade as you're looking for) James R. Chiles, Inviting Disaster: Lessons From the Edge of Technology (start with this one) Langeweische had a two-part article in the Atlantic on the airline crash caused by bad oxygen generators--cascading failures on the human rather than technical side--but it's subscriber only now. Posted by Karl Gallagher at July 29, 2005 07:42 AMPerhaps the Concorde disaster could qualify. Its still Aerospace related though. On take off a tire is slit open by a peice of metal that fell of an aircraft that took off just prior. The tire disintergrates and a chunk of tire weighing several pounds thunks against the underside of the wing. Even though the peice of tire doesn't penetrate through the aircraft skin it produces a shockwave of energy that propogates throughout the fuel contained in the wing. When the shockwave reaches the leading edge of the wing it finds a way out through a service panel. This causes fuel to burst out through the service panel and spray out over the number 2 engine. The hot exhaust of the engine ignites the fuel spray and begins to melt through the aircraft skin and control surfaces of the wing. Eventually the wing degrades to the point where it can no longer control the aircraft. "Set Phasers on Stun" treats a collection of 20 or so engineering failures lightly as somewhat fictional stories told from the point of view of the people who were involved (either directly or afterwards). It provides real references. Posted by Karl Hallowell at July 29, 2005 09:27 AMThe Bonefish fire isn't a particularly good example - it's a fairly straightforward casualty. (One interesting note: The seawater leak was the result of poor maintenance and preservation.) A better is example is Thresher where what is believed to have been a minor casualty (a small leak) cascaded into something much greater because the leak disabled the propulsion system. The ultimate cause of the loss was poor design and construction of the very system supposed to save their lives - the Emergency Main Ballast Tank Blow system. Posted by Derek L. at July 29, 2005 10:16 AMForgot to add; Another interesting book on technological accidents is: Perrow, Charles; Normal Accidents. Posted by Derek L. at July 29, 2005 10:18 AMCheck out the NTSB for aviation reports. Just about every aviation crash follows the pattern of some small thing early on creating a chain of events leading to a crash. Posted by David Masten at July 29, 2005 10:55 AM"Arching between cables?" Gimme a break. One good thing about Wikipedia is that annoying spelling or grammatical errors are easily corrected even if you aren't an expert on the subject matter. I know a few people whose disdain for Wikipedia is particularly intense. I love it. Posted by Obi-Wan at July 29, 2005 03:44 PMRand, The ValuJet crash was a good example. Contract Maintenance improperly labels O2 generators. Nearly all submarine mishaps involve a failure cascade with 'delta P' as the instigator or finale. Well-illustrated 'coffee table' book but sparce on technical details: LOST SUBS (From the Hunley to the Kursk) Spencer Dunmore 2002 ISBN 1-903985-48-X Posted by SpaceCat at July 29, 2005 08:28 PMI learned about the Kaprun funicular fire (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaprun_disaster) from an episode of the National Geographic series mentioned above. When the decades-old trains were overhauled their appearance was updated to modern sensibilities but the mechanical work was careless. A cheap household electric heater was installed in the driver's compartment. It was overused, overheated, and ignited leaking brake fluid. The fail-safe brakes locked when deprived of fluid and held the train in the tunnel as it became a furnace. Posted by FC at July 30, 2005 03:44 AMThree Mile Island may be a good example, but there were a few critical operator errors involved in the event (i.e.: the technical failures were not *solely* responsible for the accident): - a valve in the secondary coolant loop shuts down (due to an error in maintenance work, IIRC); See generally H. Petroski's book entitled "Design Paradigms - Case Histories of Error and Judgment in Engineering" (Cambridge 1994) for discussion of, among others, Apollo Pedestal, Kansas City Regency, Dee Bridge, Tacoma Narrows and other instances which seem to present facially structurally simple design issues, perhaps even more pernicious than "complex" systems because of susceptibility to overlook subtle potential complex failure modes. Also, obviously, structural issues in Twin Towers. Also you may be familiar with USS Thresher, a nuclear sub which imploded off the Azores in the 80's when power plant failure combined with unforseen anomalies in plane and buoyancy tank design, as I think I recall from replicating the circumstances in sub trainers in Charleston in the 70's, caused loss of forward way and settling of stern, and ultimately a stern-down slide to crush depth. As an aero engineer who flew in P-3's in 1970's, I am also generally familiar with early failures of wing root structures and fatal crashes of Lockheed Electra passenger aircraft (civilian P-3 counterpart), and subsequent reduction of wing length and controlling propeller rotational speed to prevent harmonics which caused the wings to fail (so-called "whirl mode failure"). Perhaps most insidious failures aboard the P-3, however, involved failure of coffee pot or electric skillet back in crew galley, thus cutting into crew performance with consequent secondary, tertiary, quaternary cascading effects on antisubmarine mission effectiveness and consequent ultimate ire of debriefing officers on the ground (just kidding about this last). Posted by Jim Ewing at July 31, 2005 01:01 PMPost a comment |