|
Reader's Favorites
Media Casualties Mount Administration Split On Europe Invasion Administration In Crisis Over Burgeoning Quagmire Congress Concerned About Diversion From War On Japan Pot, Kettle On Line Two... Allies Seize Paris The Natural Gore Book Sales Tank, Supporters Claim Unfair Tactics Satan Files Lack Of Defamation Suit Why This Blog Bores People With Space Stuff A New Beginning My Hit Parade
Instapundit (Glenn Reynolds) Tim Blair James Lileks Bleats Virginia Postrel Kausfiles Winds Of Change (Joe Katzman) Little Green Footballs (Charles Johnson) Samizdata Eject Eject Eject (Bill Whittle) Space Alan Boyle (MSNBC) Space Politics (Jeff Foust) Space Transport News (Clark Lindsey) NASA Watch NASA Space Flight Hobby Space A Voyage To Arcturus (Jay Manifold) Dispatches From The Final Frontier (Michael Belfiore) Personal Spaceflight (Jeff Foust) Mars Blog The Flame Trench (Florida Today) Space Cynic Rocket Forge (Michael Mealing) COTS Watch (Michael Mealing) Curmudgeon's Corner (Mark Whittington) Selenian Boondocks Tales of the Heliosphere Out Of The Cradle Space For Commerce (Brian Dunbar) True Anomaly Kevin Parkin The Speculist (Phil Bowermaster) Spacecraft (Chris Hall) Space Pragmatism (Dan Schrimpsher) Eternal Golden Braid (Fred Kiesche) Carried Away (Dan Schmelzer) Laughing Wolf (C. Blake Powers) Chair Force Engineer (Air Force Procurement) Spacearium Saturn Follies JesusPhreaks (Scott Bell) Science
Nanobot (Howard Lovy) Lagniappe (Derek Lowe) Geek Press (Paul Hsieh) Gene Expression Carl Zimmer Redwood Dragon (Dave Trowbridge) Charles Murtaugh Turned Up To Eleven (Paul Orwin) Cowlix (Wes Cowley) Quark Soup (Dave Appell) Economics/Finance
Assymetrical Information (Jane Galt and Mindles H. Dreck) Marginal Revolution (Tyler Cowen et al) Man Without Qualities (Robert Musil) Knowledge Problem (Lynne Kiesling) Journoblogs The Ombudsgod Cut On The Bias (Susanna Cornett) Joanne Jacobs The Funny Pages
Cox & Forkum Day By Day Iowahawk Happy Fun Pundit Jim Treacher IMAO The Onion Amish Tech Support (Lawrence Simon) Scrapple Face (Scott Ott) Regular Reading
Quasipundit (Adragna & Vehrs) England's Sword (Iain Murray) Daily Pundit (Bill Quick) Pejman Pundit Daimnation! (Damian Penny) Aspara Girl Flit Z+ Blog (Andrew Zolli) Matt Welch Ken Layne The Kolkata Libertarian Midwest Conservative Journal Protein Wisdom (Jeff Goldstein et al) Dean's World (Dean Esmay) Yippee-Ki-Yay (Kevin McGehee) Vodka Pundit Richard Bennett Spleenville (Andrea Harris) Random Jottings (John Weidner) Natalie Solent On the Third Hand (Kathy Kinsley, Bellicose Woman) Patrick Ruffini Inappropriate Response (Moira Breen) Jerry Pournelle Other Worthy Weblogs
Ain't No Bad Dude (Brian Linse) Airstrip One A libertarian reads the papers Andrew Olmsted Anna Franco Review Ben Kepple's Daily Rant Bjorn Staerk Bitter Girl Catallaxy Files Dawson.com Dodgeblog Dropscan (Shiloh Bucher) End the War on Freedom Fevered Rants Fredrik Norman Heretical Ideas Ideas etc Insolvent Republic of Blogistan James Reuben Haney Libertarian Rant Matthew Edgar Mind over what matters Muslimpundit Page Fault Interrupt Photodude Privacy Digest Quare Rantburg Recovering Liberal Sand In The Gears(Anthony Woodlief) Sgt. Stryker The Blogs of War The Fly Bottle The Illuminated Donkey Unqualified Offerings What she really thinks Where HipHop & Libertarianism Meet Zem : blog Space Policy Links
Space Future The Space Review The Space Show Space Frontier Foundation Space Policy Digest BBS AWOL
USS Clueless (Steven Den Beste) Media Minder Unremitting Verse (Will Warren) World View (Brink Lindsay) The Last Page More Than Zero (Andrew Hofer) Pathetic Earthlings (Andrew Lloyd) Spaceship Summer (Derek Lyons) The New Space Age (Rob Wilson) Rocketman (Mark Oakley) Mazoo Site designed by Powered by Movable Type |
Brought Down By Arrogance Darth Groznii says that the Order of the Jedi deserved to be destroyed. It seems like a sound analysis to me. Posted by Rand Simberg at May 09, 2005 09:04 AMTrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.transterrestrial.com/mt-diagnostics.cgi/3783 Listed below are links to weblogs that reference this post from Transterrestrial Musings.
Second Opinions
Excerpt: Rand Simberg of Transterrestrial Musings posted this link weeks ago, but I've been too lazy to point it out. Till now. Cause I know you want it. The Jedi Order’s mistakes in dealing with Anakin Skywalker are numerous and damning.... Weblog: Classical Values Tracked: May 30, 2005 09:02 PM
Comments
That analysis is just BEGGING to be compared to a number of current and past world powers, and I was expecting such a comparison until I reached the end. I wonder why he stopped short? Posted by John Breen III at May 9, 2005 09:54 AMAlso this seems to be serious spoiler material. You should have a warning. I'm not prepared to discuss this subject till after I've seen the movie. It shouldn't be a spoiler--my impression from reading it was that it was based only on conjecture from viewing the trailer. Most of the criticism relates to episodes 1 and 2. Posted by Rand Simberg at May 9, 2005 11:03 AMI agree -- the Jedi aren't the pure good guys people think. In "Attack of the Clones", when Anakin reaches his mother just in time to see her die, he proceeds (as he later admits to Padme) to wipe out the Sand People settlement, men, women and children. In other words, he committed an atrocity. But the truly disturbing part is Padme's reaction. She doesn't scream and call him a child killer. She just hugs him as though to say, "that's sad but it's not like they were people so it's okay." There are no consequences for his crime. Posted by Kelly Parks at May 9, 2005 01:11 PM*cough* UN *cough* Posted by Leland at May 9, 2005 01:17 PMYou expect ethics? From George Lucas? The fans have come up with better material than he has since the first Star Wars movie. Just look at "Troops." Posted by at May 9, 2005 01:18 PMShe just hugs him as though to say, "that's sad but it's not like they were people so it's okay." Well, maybe they aren't "people" (even though they're called "sand people"). Are they sapient? Do they have any kind of system of ethics? Can they be negotiated with, with useful results? If one of their children was raised in a civilized environment, would it come out all right, or are they intrinsically bloodthirsty? I don't know enough about them to say, but it's not obvious based on what I do know that wiping out the village was any more of an atrocity than killing a bear that's developed a habit of attacking humans. Posted by Rand Simberg at May 9, 2005 01:28 PMAre they sapient? Without question. They operate vehicles and firearms and other complex tools, keep herd animals, use language, etc. They are a sentient race. Do they have any kind of system of ethics? Can they be negotiated with, with useful results? Details are sketchy but the fact that they co-exist with the other sentient races on Tatooine (with ocasional skirmishes rather than eternal war) makes me think they can be dealt with. They aren't dumb animals. They're intelligent beings. They're nasty, cut throat, barbaric intelligent beings but that doesn't make it any less an atrocity to murder their children. Posted by Kelly Parks at May 9, 2005 01:41 PMummmmm..... people: Hello? It's a MOVIE! A figment of George Lucas' imagination and a bolster to his bank account(s). Settle down now, relax- everything will be OK. -Oh, and don't turn out like those worthless Trekkies that have been put down here several times in the last week or so. Posted by DC at May 9, 2005 08:46 PMBest reason they deserved to be brought down: They were stupid. "He's the chosen one who will bring balance to the force." "Well, maybe they aren't "people" (even though they're called "sand people")." Dude, you just flunked Lucas's little gratuitous exercise in colonial history. As you can see, they make crude nomadic type huts and live in tribal groups. They've even domesticated some of the local wildlife. I submit that they are, in fact, the "native" population of the planet, before the "white men" moved in to take it over and cut up their happy hunting grounds with moisture farms and cantinas. Enslaving and/or torturing enemy captives to death as an evening's entertainment is not all that rare amoungst native tribes. If the sandpeople are the native population, where did the Jawas come from? Posted by McGehee at May 10, 2005 09:03 AMTo get back to the topic here, yes, the Jedi deserve to be destroyed, but for other reasons, perhaps: They act as an enforcement arm of the government, but what checks or balances are there? They seem to have Carte Blanche to do whatever they want, including killing people. Who watches the watchers? They take young children from their parents (perhaps with permission) and keep them separated from them, either forever, or for long periods of time. By the time the young Jedi is of an age to choose for himself, he is brainwashed beyond choosing. Other points raised: Yes, the Jedi should have gotten Anakin's mother out of hock, but why didn't Padme? She knew what her situation was, and the boy had just saved her planet. Why wouldn't she have sent people to extract the mother from Tatooine? Gaping plot hole, George. Also, by introducing the Qui-gon character, George kind of cheats on Obi-wan's moral choices. It is no longer Obi-wan's choice to train Anakin; he is doing it because of his master's dying wish. Blurs the lines of responsibility. End of rant. Posted by John K Berntson at May 10, 2005 09:15 AM"If the sandpeople are the native population, where did the Jawas come from? Geek moment. Ahem. It's heavily implied, if not outright stated in Knights of the Old Republic (2, I think), that the Jawas are as close to the original inhabitants of Tatooine as anyone knows. The Sand People (Tusken Raiders) are old, but not as old as the Jawas. Tatooine apparently has a long, long history of being colonized, having the colonies collapse, and being colonized again, over and over. Now, granted, none of this is from the movies, so, grain of salt and all. Posted by Noah Doyle at May 10, 2005 11:16 AMPost a comment |